Every Mafia Game Ranked
Mafia spans 4 critic-rated games on CriticDB, released between 2002 and 2025. The highest-rated is Mafia: Definitive Edition (79) and the lowest is Mafia III (67). Across 89 critic reviews, the series averages 72, and Mafia: The Old Country has drawn the most reviews.
- 1
Mafia: Definitive Edition
7927 critic reviews·Sep 24, 2020·2K GamesPCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1“Debuting back in 2002, the original Mafia is now available for modern consoles as a remake so let's go back to the '30s and join the mob.”
- 2
Mafia: The Old Country
7241 critic reviews·Aug 6, 2025·2K GamesPCPS5Xbox X|S“Mafia: The Old Country delivers a competently crafted but ultimately underwhelming prequel that falls short of franchise expectations.”
- 3
Mafia II: Definitive Edition
6910 critic reviews·May 18, 2020·2K GamesPCPS4Xbox One“Mafia II: Definitive Edition offers a fantastic tale combined with a solid set of visual upgrades. Unfortunately, it is hampered by bugs and some missing quality of life upgrades.”
- 4
Mafia III
6711 critic reviews·Oct 6, 2016·Take-Two InteractivePCPS4Xbox One“With a great narrative and intelligent writing Mafia III’s story holds up great but the fact that players have to deal with a repetitive mission structure while facing off against poor AI with easy to use but…”