Every NHL Game Ranked
NHL spans 14 critic-rated games on CriticDB, released between 2012 and 2026. The highest-rated is NHL 14 (81) and the lowest is NHL 15 (58). Across 132 critic reviews, the series averages 73, and NHL 19 has drawn the most reviews.
- 1

NHL 14
819 critic reviews·Sep 9, 2013·EA SportsPS3Xbox 360“EA Sports takes its NHL series in a more realistic direction with a new skating system.”
- 2

NHL 18
808 critic reviews·Sep 14, 2017·EA SportsPS4Xbox One“Threes is definitely the star of the show in NHL 18 with only marginal improvements made to the rest of the franchise's modes.”
- 3

NHL 16
798 critic reviews·Sep 14, 2015·EA SportsPS4Xbox One“While some game modes still feel like they are living in the past, the return of fan-favorites like EASHL and the improved Be A Pro make NHL 16 a power play that hockey fans are bound to love.”
- 4

NHL 17
7912 critic reviews·Sep 12, 2016·EA SportsPS4Xbox One“When compared to NHL 15, NHL 17 is miles ahead; when compared to NHL 16, it’s incrementally better. That’s the EA Sports way. There are some new features and improvements, but nothing mind-blowingly innovative.”
- 5

NHL 20
7912 critic reviews·Sep 12, 2019·EA SportsPS4Xbox One“Depending on the mode you like to play, NHL 20 is a winner or a loser. The on-ice action improves thanks to the reworked shooting system, and the World of Chel arcade modes gain a little more depth.”
- 6

NHL 19
7913 critic reviews·Sep 13, 2018·EA SportsPS4Xbox One“NHL 19 is a clear step up from previous installments of the franchise. With its large list of game modes, features, and customization options, NHL helps elevate the series in ways both familiar and totally new.”
- 7

NHL 21
759 critic reviews·Oct 15, 2020·Electronic ArtsPS4Xbox One“NHL 21 provides more of the same, and with the uncertainty of the real world season, even less of what few changes fans come to expect of yearly releases.”
- 8

NHL 24
7510 critic reviews·Oct 5, 2023·EA SportsPS4Xbox OnePS5Xbox X|S“A fine game of ice hockey, NHL 24 improves upon last year's instalment, offering some slick new features, and all of the usual modes and other accoutrements you'd expect, all nicely presented.”
- 9

NHL 26
718 critic reviews·Sep 11, 2025·EA SportsPS5Xbox X|S“With a number of improvements such as a new goalie crease system and NHL EDGE data being used to enhance player behaviour, NHL 26 is undoubtedly a great hockey game.”
- 10

NHL 22
718 critic reviews·Oct 10, 2021·EA SportsPS4Xbox OnePS5Xbox X|S“NHL 22 does an excellent job at bringing back old arcade-y mechanics and blending it with today's simulation quality presentation in a way that works together rather than against itself.”
- 11

NHL 23
696 critic reviews·Oct 13, 2022·EA SportsPS4Xbox OnePS5Xbox X|S“Despite the addition of women players in HUT and tweaked mechanics like last-chance puck movements, NHL 23 barely feels it's changed from last year's offering. It's a fun but all too familiar hockey experience.”
- 12

NHL 25
688 critic reviews·Oct 3, 2024·EA SportsPS5Xbox X|S“NHL 25 is a good game when it focuses on hockey, it’s when microtransactions come into play that things become tacky.”
- 13

NHL 27
639 critic reviews·Sep 10, 2026·EA SportsPS5Xbox X|S“NHL 27 (PlayStation 5) Review – 6.5/10: It’s evident NHL 27 is a leap year for the franchise as it doesn’t innovate on the modes and immersion already present.”
- 14

NHL 15
5812 critic reviews·Sep 8, 2014·EA SportsPS3Xbox 360PS4Xbox One“Compared to previous efforts, NHL 15 falls incredibly short on new-gen platforms. Missing a swathe of modes, you can't help but feel that the franchise's debut on Xbox One and PlayStation 4 is something of a puck up.”