
Under the Island Reviews
Check out Under the Island Review Scores from trusted Critics below. With 17 reviews on CriticDB, Under the Island has a score of:
For fans of classic adventure games, pixel art lovers, and players who appreciate world exploration over narrative complexity, I cannot recommend Under The Island highly enough. It’s a delightful journey worth taking, whether you’re solving puzzles in a strange greenhouse or feeding treats to helpful critters in snowy caverns, the experience always feels personal, inviting, and thoroughly engaging.
Reminiscent of Link to the Past but with enough charm and ingenuity to boldly stand out, Under the Island is a gorgeous and imaginative action-adventure that tasks you with saving your home island. It's utterly joyous, and even the odd spike in combat difficulty isn't enough to spoil your fun.
The game’s run-time is in the range of 8 to 12 hours, depending on how much you want to explore the world and complete side quests, and it will leave players wanting more. It’s almost disappointing when the narrative all wraps up, as the infectious charm at the heart of the experience will leave players wanting more. That’s better than over-stretching, but it also means the game doesn’t have the larger scope that it could probably benefit from. Still, there’s a lot to love about Under the Island. Even beyond the throwback vibes and solid gameplay, the visual and music presentation ma…
As Nia moves to a new town, her life gets turned upside down when the ground swallows her up to then place her on the journey of a whole new adventure. Under the Island was a pleasant surprise, and a wonderful delight.
Seashell Island may look calm on the surface, but the real adventure waits beneath your feet! Under the Island is a 2D action adventure developed by Slime
Seashell Island is sinking and it's up to you to find the lost gears to save it in this Zelda-like adventure rich with puzzles and adorable critters.
Just like with my kids’ elaborate games and worlds they think up, it may not all make sense, but it didn’t stop me from having a great time. Under the Island is a fun and often wacky adventure game that wears its heart on its sleeve and does right by its inspirations. It’s a game that begs to be explored from top to bottom, with the intent of giving the player something to find or do at nearly every turn. I loved my time on Seashell Island, and I think that plenty of other people will too.
While I can certainly appreciate the scale and beauty of modern Zelda games, I do miss the old school style of dungeons and power upgrades on a 2D plane. This always draws me to games that are influenced by the SNES era of Zelda, and I’m happy to report that Under the Island is one of the most polished and successful in quite a while. The atmosphere, puzzles, level of challenge, and story are all satisfyingly designed to produce a game that wears its influences well.
A very well-executed and beautiful Zelda-like game in a tranquil setting.
Under The Island didn't take long to sink its charming teeth into me as I had been itching for something a little lighter, both in tone and runtime, after making my way through a handful of long RPGs. Along Nia’s adventure, you end up encountering a variety of different gameplay types, including stealth sequences and arcade-style minigames, and so what has become a well-trod genre does feel quite fresh. If you're in the mood for a whimsical Zelda-like with some unique items and boss fights, the dozen-plus hours you can spend on Seashell Island are absolutely worth your time.
That said, I would still recommend the game, especially to people who really enjoy puzzle games. In my opinion, there are enough positive aspects of the game to outweigh the parts that I didn’t enjoy that much.
Under The Island is a fun little jaunt that is brimming with personality. The game’s excellent balance makes explorationthe consistently rewarding, while solid puzzling and a bright narrative help to round out experience.
Under the Island falters in its combat and storytelling, but more than makes up for those shortcomings with engaging world design, clever puzzles, and creative boss encounters. Link’s boots are admittedly difficult to fill, but Under the Island has enough good ideas to set itself apart from its inspiration. The journey is a short one at only eight to ten hours, but I enjoyed my time with the game. It’s no Link’s Awakening, but in its best moments, it gets close enough to scratch the old-school Zelda itch.
Under the Island sees Nia quickly rush into an adventure to prevent her new home from sinking. Despite lacking enough to really stand out from the crowd, solid puzzles and charm have enough to keep players engaged.
Under the Island is a bright and colorful game, but much like the ominous and vast hidden undercity the heroines encounter, it isn’t all it appears to be. Under the Island is plagued by bugs, a lack of gameplay polish, and frustration.
Under The Island mixes up elements of Stardew Valley and The Legend of Zelda, and it’s available now on the Switch, PS5, PC, and Xbox.
Under the Island is a loving tribute to the legendary top-down Zelda games. It’s set in a beautifully imaginative world and successfully adopts the best parts of the genre: a solid Metroidvania format, challenging enemies, and clever puzzles that don’t hold your hand. By infusing the classic concept with modern perks like Fast Travel and character upgrades, Slime King Games has created a highly entertaining 2D action RPG crafted with immense care and charm. To put it simply: it’s a must-play for anyone with a heart for nostalgic adventure.