Andrew Kirkcaldy
This author account hasn't been claimed yet. To claim this account, please contact the outlet owner to request access.
Writing For
Latest Reviews
Ezio's story comes to a disappointing conclusion in the weakest Assassin's Creed since the original.
Super Mario 3D Land is a step back and a leap forward. As a gateway drug for those reluctant to embrace Mario in three dimensions, the game should be a huge success.
Despite inconsistencies, Lego Batman 2: DC Super Heroes is a great Lego game.
NieR: Automata has more creativity and self-awareness in its little finger than most games have for their entire run time. Don’t miss this because it’s sandwiched between other, bigger games.
Dark and beautiful, you’ll come for Hollow Knight’s visual appeal, but you’ll stay for the challenge and responsive combat.
After the impressive voice acting and general spectacle of the main adventure starts to fade, you’re left with an altogether dull world in which to roam.
A rewarding, idiosyncratic romp imbued with nonsense, humour, and pathos.
Rayman Legends isn't perfect, but it's still a cracking game.
Enjoyable in shorter sessions, but too easy and grind-heavy to warrant lengthy play.
The strongest Lego title yet, and the best Marvel game ever made.
CriticDB tracks 76 Andrew Kirkcaldy reviews, averaging 73/100. See the score distribution and their highest & lowest rated games below, or browse every Andrew Kirkcaldy score in the Reviews tab.
Andrew Kirkcaldy score distribution
- 90–10016
- 80–8923
- 70–7922
- 60–696
- 50–594
- Below 505
















