Andrew Kirkcaldy
This author account hasn't been claimed yet. To claim this account, please contact the outlet owner to request access.
Writing For
Latest Reviews
It’s not bad, but it lacks imagination outside of the singular gimmick that you can change vehicles at any time, and ends up just being rather average.
A worthy, if slightly flawed, successor to the original game.
A complex and enjoyable JRPG, if not a brilliant one.
An offline bomb, Payday 2 erupts into quite the beast when taken online.
Fans of the original game and the superior Dynasty Warriors series may find something to enjoy here, but everyone else will be hard pressed to do the same.
Like a mug of Earl Grey with a dash of cocaine. Quirky, erudite and astonishingly addictive. How civilized.
As an expansion pack, this is both Special Forces and Special Needs in equal measure. Whilst it adds some welcome new toys, it doesn't address the more serious technical issues of the original.
So basically, this new BattleZone succeeds - if by the skin of its teeth - in becoming an entertaining title.
Like KotOR 2 before it, Neverwinter Nights 2 promises much without quite delivering its full potential. A slow start and numerous bugs prevent it from being truly great.
With its spectacular design, dazzling polish and ever-compulsive gameplay, World of Warcraft seems destined to remain the everyman's pick of PvE-focussed MMO for the foreseeable future.
Company of Heroes doesn't so much raise the bar for RTS games, but twists it into knots and blasts it into orbit.
If KotOR 2 was a sandwich, it'd be caviar on mouldy rye. The bit in the middle is fabulous, but the rest will leave a bitter taste in the mouth.
CriticDB tracks 76 Andrew Kirkcaldy reviews, averaging 73/100. See the score distribution and their highest & lowest rated games below, or browse every Andrew Kirkcaldy score in the Reviews tab.
Andrew Kirkcaldy score distribution
- 90–10016
- 80–8923
- 70–7922
- 60–696
- 50–594
- Below 505














