Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut artwork

Best Psychological Horror Games on Xbox Series X|S

The top 40 psychological horror games on Xbox Series X|S ranked by critic score · from 40 titles

CriticDB tracks 40 psychological horror games on Xbox Series X|S with critic scores. The highest-rated is Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut (92), followed by Resident Evil 4 (90) and Mouthwashing (90). This top 40 draws on 887 critic reviews.

  1. 1
    Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut

    Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut

    92
    10 critic reviews·Oct 23, 2024·Serenity Forge
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Slay the Princess – The Pristine Cut is a fantastic visual novel with excellent production values and a lot of dialogue options.”
    — XboxEra · 92/100
  2. 2
    Resident Evil 4

    Resident Evil 4

    90
    38 critic reviews·Mar 23, 2023·Capcom
    PCPS4PS5Xbox X|S +1
    “More than eleven years have passed since Resident Evil 4 first hit Nintendo’s GameCube, and since then many competitors have attempted to topple its status as the king of survival horror.”
    — COGConnected · 90/100
  3. 3
    Mouthwashing

    Mouthwashing

    90
    20 critic reviews·Sep 25, 2024·Critical Reflex
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Review: First-person horror Mouthwashing will keep you on the edge of your seat as you unravel its dark and gripping story.”
    — GameSpew · 90/100
  4. 4
    Alan Wake II

    Alan Wake II

    88
    25 critic reviews·Oct 26, 2023·Epic Games
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    ““It’s not a lake, it’s an ocean” are the words that have been in the heads of Alan Wake fans for years. Remedy’s 2010 action-horror masterpiece delivered one of the wildest and most compelling mysteries.”
    — WayTooManyGames · 90/100
  5. 5
    Resident Evil 7: Biohazard

    Resident Evil 7: Biohazard

    87
    33 critic reviews·Jan 23, 2017·Capcom
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +2
    “The Resident Evil series has had a profound effect on me as a gamer – The original game was the first title I played on the PlayStation and I remember 13 year”
    — Impulse Gamer · 88/100
  6. 6
    Silent Hill 2

    Silent Hill 2

    87
    26 critic reviews·Oct 7, 2024·Konami
    PCPS2PS5Xbox X|S
    “Remaking one of the most revered horror games ever is no simple task, but Bloober Team impressively rebottles the magic of the 2001 genre landmark.”
    — GameSpot · 90/100
  7. 7
    Silent Hill f

    Silent Hill f

    85
    55 critic reviews·Sep 24, 2025·Konami
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “Silent Hill f is a completely new story set in 1960s Japan featuring a beautiful, yet horrifying world.”
    — Worth Playing · 85/100
  8. 8
    Dredge

    Dredge

    85
    32 critic reviews·Mar 29, 2023·Team17
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Prepare for a fishing trip filled with hapless inhabitants, mysterious far-flung islands, and seas that are brimming with deep, dark secrets.”
    — Worth Playing · 85/100
  9. 9
    Signalis

    Signalis

    85
    24 critic reviews·Oct 26, 2022·Humble Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +1
    “Signalis is a classic survival-horror experience with a unique aesthetic, full of melancholic mystery.”
    — Worth Playing · 85/100
  10. 10
    Control

    Control

    84
    48 critic reviews·Aug 26, 2019·505 Games
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “When the issues of a game are rolled and stomped by its greatness, then it’s something to invest on if you have some spare.”
    — Sirus Gaming · 83/100
  11. 11
    Luto

    Luto

    84
    9 critic reviews·Jul 21, 2025·Broken Bird Games
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “A short, yet fantastic horror game. A masterclass in storytelling and atmosphere.”
    — GameGrin · 85/100
  12. 12
    Senua's Saga: Hellblade II

    Senua's Saga: Hellblade II

    83
    42 critic reviews·May 20, 2024·Xbox Game Studios
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “Sequels are often predictable, but Senua's Saga: Hellblade 2 surprised fans with its unexpected continuation of Senua's story.”
    — Lords of Gaming · 85/100
  13. 13
    Tenebris Somnia

    Tenebris Somnia

    82
    17 critic reviews·Oct 15, 2026·New Blood Interactive
    PCSwitchPS5Xbox X|S +1
    “Tenebris Somnia fused retro 2D pixel art with lavish filmed cutscenes for a dramatic and compelling horror tale.”
    — TheSixthAxis · 80/100
  14. 14
    Routine

    Routine

    81
    21 critic reviews·Dec 3, 2025·Raw Fury
    PCXbox OneXbox X|S
    “ROUTINE may have been a long time coming, but it’s definitely well worth the experience now that it’s finally here, especially for fans of the horror genre.”
    — GamingBolt · 80/100
  15. 15
    Observer: System Redux

    Observer: System Redux

    81
    19 critic reviews·Nov 9, 2020·Bloober Team
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +2
    “A graphical feast that seamlessly blends a multilayered, psychological horror narrative with heart-poundingly and intimate gameplay, Observer: System Redux is an exquisite piece of cyberpunk fiction.”
    — NoobFeed · 90/100
  16. 16
    Raging Loop

    Raging Loop

    81
    5 critic reviews·Dec 2, 2015·PQube
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “While it takes a while to establish the plot, Raging Loop is a visual novel that’s grisly and heartfelt.”
    — GamingTrend · 80/100
  17. 17
    Darkest Dungeon II

    Darkest Dungeon II

    80
    26 critic reviews·May 7, 2023·Red Hook Studios
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +3
    “Darkest Dungeon II is a challenging gothic roguelike RPG that will test your mettle and drive you to the brink of madness.”
    — Worth Playing · 80/100
  18. 18
    Amnesia: Rebirth

    Amnesia: Rebirth

    80
    35 critic reviews·Oct 19, 2020·Frictional Games
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +2
    “The follow-up to Frictional Games' seminal 2010 horror game tightly hones the developer's approach to story, frights, and frustration.”
    — GameSpot · 80/100
  19. 19
    Amnesia: The Bunker

    Amnesia: The Bunker

    79
    41 critic reviews·Jun 5, 2023·Frictional Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneXbox X|S
    “The year is 1916. You are Henri Clement, a French soldier fighting in World War I. You went searching for your friend on the battlefield, and, after getting”
    — Impulse Gamer · 80/100
  20. 20
    The Outlast Trials

    The Outlast Trials

    78
    28 critic reviews·Mar 4, 2024·Red Barrels
    PCPlayStationXboxPS4 +4
    “Red Barrels' third Outlast game is a departure in many ways, but remains memorable for its twisted villains and the grotesque world they inhabit.”
    — GameSpot · 80/100
  21. 21
    Clem

    Clem

    77
    7 critic reviews·Feb 5, 2024·Iceberg Interactive
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Despite the occasional patience-testing puzzle, CLeM’s inventive gameplay and exploratory style make this quirky hand-drawn “Psychotic Adventure” worth a peek.”
    — Adventure Game Hotspot · 78/100
  22. 22
    In Sound Mind

    In Sound Mind

    74
    13 critic reviews·Sep 27, 2021·Modus Games
    PCSwitchPS5Xbox X|S
    “While some obscure paths and crashing issues hold In Sound Mind back from greatness, the game still has a lot going for it.”
    — TechRaptor · 75/100
  23. 23
    Karma: The Dark World

    Karma: The Dark World

    74
    15 critic reviews·Mar 26, 2025·Gamirror Games
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “A bewildering story is content to leave players floundering in the dark, but KARMA’s commitment to nonstop weirdness provides some gloriously unhinged nightmare fuel.”
    — Adventure Game Hotspot · 73/100
  24. 24
    No One Lives Under the Lighthouse

    No One Lives Under the Lighthouse

    73
    5 critic reviews·Apr 20, 2020·Puppet Combo
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “No One Lives Under the Lighthouse is a game that horror fans should definitely check out, especially if the retro aesthetic appeals to them.”
    — GameSpew · 70/100
  25. 25
    Sleep Awake

    Sleep Awake

    73
    12 critic reviews·Dec 1, 2025·Blumhouse Games
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “Sleep Awake has an interesting premise, and makes nice use of full motion video to assist in blurring the lines between what's real and imaginary. It's just a shame that it's not as engaging to play as it should be.”
    — GameSpew · 70/100
  26. 26
    Pathologic 3

    Pathologic 3

    72
    8 critic reviews·Jan 8, 2026·HypeTrain Digital
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “Given a little more time to cook, Pathologic 3 would be an easy recommendation to players looking to see what this cult series is about.”
    — WellPlayed · 75/100
  27. 27
    The Medium

    The Medium

    71
    54 critic reviews·Jan 27, 2021·Bloober Team
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “It's been a few months yet The Medium is finally available for PlayStation 5 and it's quite an intriguing horror game so let's get to it.”
    — Video Chums · 72/100
  28. 28
    The Cabin Factory

    The Cabin Factory

    70
    5 critic reviews·Dec 12, 2024·Future Friends Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Your job at the Cabin Factory is simple: inspect the cabins and decide on whether they’re haunted or not. If you do find any anomalies, get out…immediately. PC version reviewed.”
    — Siliconera · 70/100
  29. 29
    Cthulhu: The Cosmic Abyss

    Cthulhu: The Cosmic Abyss

    69
    26 critic reviews·Apr 15, 2026·Nacon
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “While there are many games based on the works of H.P. Lovecraft, Cthulhu: The Cosmic Abyss stands out thanks to its focus on you conducting an investigation.”
    — GameSpew · 70/100
  30. 30
    The Occultist

    The Occultist

    69
    15 critic reviews·Apr 7, 2026·Daedalic Entertainment
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “Taking on the role of a paranormal investigator, The Occultist gives you multiple unique abilities to make use of as you explore areas and solve an assortment of puzzles.”
    — GameSpew · 70/100
  31. 31
    Scorn

    Scorn

    68
    34 critic reviews·Oct 13, 2022·Ebb Software
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “Scorn is clearly a labour of grotesque love, feeling unlike almost any other game out there.”
    — TheSixthAxis · 70/100
  32. 32
    The Mound: Omen of Cthulhu

    The Mound: Omen of Cthulhu

    68
    20 critic reviews·Jul 14, 2026·Nacon
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “The Mound: Omen of Cthulhu delivers a strong Lovecraftian atmosphere and tense co-op ideas, but its clunky combat, weak solo play, and performance issues hold it back.”
    — KeenGamer · 68/100
  33. 33
    Fobia: St. Dinfna Hotel

    Fobia: St. Dinfna Hotel

    68
    17 critic reviews·Jun 27, 2022·Maximum Games
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “Fobia – St. Dinfna Hotel is worth playing for patient survival horror fans who want something lighter on combat, and can handle budget-constrained rough edges.”
    — Destructoid · 65/100
  34. 34
    Industria

    Industria

    66
    5 critic reviews·Sep 29, 2021·Headup Games
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “INDUSTRIA delivers a solid 2-hour adventure with mysteries, profound moments, and satisfying combat encounters.”
    — NoobFeed · 70/100
  35. 35
    A.I.L.A

    A.I.L.A

    66
    13 critic reviews·Nov 24, 2025·Fireshine Games
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “A.I.L.A. is a fantastic looking game that makes a great first impression. However, spending a few hours with it is enough to expose some of its flaws, including strange puzzles and a lack of coherence between the…”
    — GamingBolt · 70/100
  36. 36
    Alone in the Dark

    Alone in the Dark

    65
    53 critic reviews·Mar 19, 2024·THQ Nordic
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “There are bright spots here that genre veterans can and likely will latch on to, but Alone in the Dark feels a bit too rough and unpolished in areas that are too critical to the experience to ever be able to truly meet…”
    — GamingBolt · 60/100
  37. 37
    Finding Frankie

    Finding Frankie

    64
    8 critic reviews·Oct 24, 2024·Mascot Bro Studio
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “Finding Frankie is a mostly fun parkour experience with interesting levels and enemies, but the clunky controls are hard to ignore in this movement-focused title, and the lack of horror won’t satisfy those looking for…”
    — GameGrin · 65/100
  38. 38
    Bad Cheese

    Bad Cheese

    63
    8 critic reviews·Aug 31, 2025·Feardemic
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “I thoroughly enjoyed my time with Bad Cheese and would recommend it to anyone who likes things on the weirder side of life.”
    — Gamer Social Club · 65/100
  39. 39
    Chasing Static

    Chasing Static

    58
    8 critic reviews·Oct 13, 2021·Ratalaika Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Spotty connection of certain design & narrative choices aside, Headware Games' retro-horror title will do just enough to keep fans from changing the channel.One of the industry’s most intriguing resurgences is the…”
    — VGChartz · 60/100
  40. 40
    Pneumata

    Pneumata

    48
    7 critic reviews·Sep 19, 2024·Deadbolt Interactive
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “What’s the biggest advantage of being a solo developer? You work on your own. And the biggest disadvantage? Also: you work on your own. As a result, an”
    — Impulse Gamer · 56/100