Baldur's Gate 3 artwork

Best Choices Matter Games on Xbox Series X|S

The top 54 choices matter games on Xbox Series X|S ranked by critic score · from 54 titles

CriticDB tracks 54 choices matter games on Xbox Series X|S with critic scores. The highest-rated is Baldur's Gate 3 (96), followed by Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut (92) and The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt Remastered (91). This top 54 draws on 1,274 critic reviews.

  1. 1
    Baldur's Gate 3

    Baldur's Gate 3

    96
    60 critic reviews·Aug 2, 2023·Larian Studios
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “A few years ago now, before Covid started. A friend of mine finally managed to convince me to join his D&D group, I'd expressed curiosity about it for”
    — Impulse Gamer · 96/100
  2. 2
    Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut

    Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut

    92
    10 critic reviews·Oct 23, 2024·Serenity Forge
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Slay the Princess – The Pristine Cut is a fantastic visual novel with excellent production values and a lot of dialogue options.”
    — XboxEra · 92/100
  3. 3
    The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt Remastered

    The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt Remastered

    91
    7 critic reviews·Sep 28, 2026·CD Projekt RED
    PCPS5Xbox X|SSwitch 2
    “The Witcher 3 Wild Hunt Remastered makes a strong technical leap on Switch 2, pairing smooth 40 FPS gameplay with VRR, portable-friendly visuals, and extensive features.”
    — Twisted Voxel · 90/100
  4. 4
    The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe

    The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe

    90
    9 critic reviews·Apr 26, 2022·Crows Crows Crows
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “The Stanley Parable is an extremely worthwhile video game and, I would argue, one of the finest examples of meta-humor (as well as humor in general) in the medium. Just don’t read too much before you play it.”
    — Nintendo World Report · 90/100
  5. 5
    Slay the Princess

    Slay the Princess

    90
    14 critic reviews·Oct 22, 2023·Black Tabby Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut further polishes an already-splendid experience, adding more depth and replayability to one of 2023's best games.”
    — GameSpot · 90/100
  6. 6
    The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

    The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

    90
    13 critic reviews·Nov 9, 2011·Bethesda Softworks
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +4
    “Skyrim is easily one of the strongest and best examples of the Western RPG, and it further establishes Bethesda's reputation as one of the most talented and creative forces in the gaming industry.”
    — Videogamer · 90/100
  7. 7
    Dispatch

    Dispatch

    89
    42 critic reviews·Oct 21, 2025·AdHoc Studio
    PCSwitchPS5Xbox X|S +1
    “Dispatch is full of heart and jokes, and it's one of the best superhero TV shows around.”
    — PC Gamer · 89/100
  8. 8
    Disco Elysium: The Final Cut

    Disco Elysium: The Final Cut

    89
    25 critic reviews·Mar 29, 2021·ZA/UM
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “The new content added to Disco Elysium: The Final Cut is exactly what is needed to turn a great game into an amazing one.”
    — Capsule Computers · 90/100
  9. 9
    Closer the Distance

    Closer the Distance

    88
    7 critic reviews·Aug 1, 2024·Skybound Games
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “Gameplay is limited to choosing specific tasks to maintain character stats, but Closer the Distance features an intriguing concept of applying indirect influence, and is a beautifully written and very detailed…”
    — Adventure Game Hotspot · 88/100
  10. 10
    The Séance of Blake Manor

    The Séance of Blake Manor

    86
    16 critic reviews·Oct 26, 2025·Raw Fury
    PCPS5Xbox X|SSwitch 2
    “This enthralling mystery quickly had me in its ghostly grip and refused to let go.”
    — PC Gamer · 87/100
  11. 11
    Deathloop

    Deathloop

    86
    54 critic reviews·Sep 13, 2021·Bethesda Softworks
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “DEATHLOOP won't be a game for everyone—however, if you are a fan of sandbox styled titles or if you just like games like Dishonored, DEATHLOOP is a familiar feeling experience presented in a unique way that makes it…”
    — CGMagazine · 85/100
  12. 12
    Wayward Strand

    Wayward Strand

    85
    13 critic reviews·Sep 14, 2022·Ghost Pattern
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Wayward Strand offers up a uniquely Australian take on the narrative adventure game with a gorgeous art direction and moving portrayal of hard-working people in a harsh system.”
    — Press Start · 85/100
  13. 13
    The Wolf Among Us Remastered

    The Wolf Among Us Remastered

    84
    23 critic reviews·Oct 28, 2026·Telltale Games
    PCXbox OneSwitchPS5 +2
    “Whether this is your first time, your second time, or your twentieth time experiencing The Wolf Among Us, you'll gladly trade hours of your videogame time to this remaster.”
    — Playstation Universe · 85/100
  14. 14
    Citizen Sleeper

    Citizen Sleeper

    84
    18 critic reviews·May 4, 2022·Fellow Traveller
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +3
    “From its interesting design ideas to its rich world-building, Jump Over The Age's Citizen Sleeper is one of 2022's best surprises.”
    — TechRaptor · 80/100
  15. 15
    Life is Strange: True Colors

    Life is Strange: True Colors

    83
    56 critic reviews·Sep 9, 2021·Square Enix
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “What True Colors lacks in the emotional gut-wrench that the previous games have, it makes it for with a refined format that presents a story that fits right into the series and tells it in the best way seen so far.”
    — GameGrin · 85/100
  16. 16
    Fortnite

    Fortnite

    83
    7 critic reviews·Jun 28, 2020·Epic Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +3
    “Nobody thought Fortnite would still be popular this late on, but it's continued to adapt and fight for its spot at the top of the battle royale ladder.”
    — GamesRadar · 80/100
  17. 17
    Far Cry 5

    Far Cry 5

    83
    43 critic reviews·Mar 25, 2018·Ubisoft Entertainment
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “The Far Cry series takes its first trip to America with this explosive entry in Ubisoft's popular first-person shooter franchise.”
    — Video Chums · 83/100
  18. 18
    Paradise Killer

    Paradise Killer

    82
    22 critic reviews·Sep 3, 2020·Fellow Traveller
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “The first time I heard about Paradise Killer was in a random message on Discord from a friend of mine. The message simply said “You should play Paradise”
    — Impulse Gamer · 80/100
  19. 19
    Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous

    Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous

    81
    19 critic reviews·Sep 1, 2021·Prime Matter
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Wrath of the Righteous is a deep, engaging, faithful recreation of the tabletop campaign with only minor flaws.”
    — GamingTrend · 80/100
  20. 20
    Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden

    Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden

    80
    52 critic reviews·Feb 12, 2024·Focus Entertainment
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden is a fantastic piece of storytelling, and it gives you a compelling world, people and lore for you to delve into.”
    — TheSixthAxis · 80/100
  21. 21
    Sundered

    Sundered

    80
    18 critic reviews·Jul 27, 2017·Thunder Lotus
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +1
    “Sundered is an interesting take on the Metroidvania genre. Eshe's journey to collect the elder shards is adrenaline fueled and challenging.”
    — TechRaptor · 80/100
  22. 22
    Bramble: The Mountain King

    Bramble: The Mountain King

    79
    15 critic reviews·Apr 26, 2023·Dimfrost Studio
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Lillemore is one of the most rotten sisters in history. You’ll see why as we go along in Bramble: The Mountain King, Dimfrost Studios and Merge Games’ horror adventure that fully earns its M rating.Read More”
    — Pure Nintendo · 80/100
  23. 23
    Thirsty Suitors

    Thirsty Suitors

    79
    25 critic reviews·Nov 1, 2023·Annapurna Interactive
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “In Thirsty Suitors, protagonist Jala has had a bad break-up and moved back to the hometown she left under the shadow of darkness, and back to the people she left high and dry.”
    — Push Square · 80/100
  24. 24
    Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon

    Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon

    78
    23 critic reviews·May 22, 2025·Awaken Realms
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon is an open-world action RPG that fans of the likes of Skyrim are likely to fall in love with.”
    — GameSpew · 80/100
  25. 25
    The Big Con

    The Big Con

    78
    11 critic reviews·Aug 30, 2021·Mighty Yell
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “The Big Con is a blast from the past in its setting and story. While the tools to get you where you need to go need a bit of work, Ali is an exceptional main character, and playing through her story is a lot of fun.”
    — GamingTrend · 75/100
  26. 26
    Dying Light 2: Stay Human

    Dying Light 2: Stay Human

    77
    35 critic reviews·Feb 2, 2022·Spike Chunsoft
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “Dying Light 2 is here after 6 years of development! You can tell care was put into this AAA title, but how is the overall gameplay, the co-op functionality, ...”
    — PSX Extreme · 78/100
  27. 27
    Far Cry 6

    Far Cry 6

    77
    47 critic reviews·Oct 6, 2021·Ubisoft Entertainment
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “If Far Cry 3 was the last game you really got into, or the modern Far Cry formula is your meaty open-world experience of choice that somehow never loses its potency, you’ll find a lot of comfort in Far Cry 6.”
    — Destructoid · 75/100
  28. 28
    Endling: Extinction is Forever

    Endling: Extinction is Forever

    77
    14 critic reviews·Jul 18, 2022·HandyGames
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “I love animals. I love animals so much that in my excitement to review a game about cute foxes, I never saw the horrible truth of what this game really is... A”
    — Pure Nintendo · 80/100
  29. 29
    Haven

    Haven

    76
    22 critic reviews·Dec 2, 2020·The Game Bakers
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “When Furi first launched back in 2016 I was blown away by its high-octane, synthwave-infused, boss rush gameplay loop that was equal parts challenging as it was epic.”
    — WayTooManyGames · 80/100
  30. 30
    Meg's Monster

    Meg's Monster

    76
    5 critic reviews·Mar 1, 2023·Odencat
    PCXbox OneSwitchPS5 +1
    “It’s a good thing the story of Meg’s Monster is engaging because even if the gameplay cleverly ties into the narrative, it doesn’t amount to much.”
    — Nintendo World Report · 75/100
  31. 31
    S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2: Heart of Chornobyl

    S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2: Heart of Chornobyl

    75
    47 critic reviews·Nov 19, 2024·GSC Game World
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2: Heart of Chornobyl is a captivating sequel with immersive world-building, intense combat, and rewarding survival mechanics. A must-play for fans and newcomers alike.”
    — NoobFeed · 76/100
  32. 32
    The Thaumaturge

    The Thaumaturge

    75
    33 critic reviews·Mar 3, 2024·11 bit studios
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “While the investigation aspect may fall a little short, The Thaumaturge is saved by excellent writing and characters. Not to mention a deeply involved combat and upgrade system.”
    — TechRaptor · 80/100
  33. 33
    Afterlove EP

    Afterlove EP

    75
    16 critic reviews·Feb 13, 2025·Fellow Traveller
    PCPS4SwitchPS5 +1
    “Afterlove EP pulls from a deep emotional well to weave threads of grief, love, hope, resentment, forgiveness, identity and more through a mostly-good mix of choice-driven visual novel and rhythm game.”
    — WellPlayed · 75/100
  34. 34
    Inkonbini

    Inkonbini

    75
    5 critic reviews·Apr 29, 2026·Beep Japan
    PCPS4SwitchPS5 +2
    “A warm, nostalgic story wrapped in the soothing rhythm of late-night convenience store life.”
    — TheGamer · 80/100
  35. 35
    Stray Gods: The Roleplaying Musical

    Stray Gods: The Roleplaying Musical

    75
    29 critic reviews·Aug 9, 2023·Humble Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “After all, you’ll find some of the most engaging characters around since Gaider’s previous stint at BioWare, and a worthwhile story in this sleeper hit. I know I have my eyes on Summerfall Studios moving forward.”
    — Destructoid · 75/100
  36. 36
    Cyberpunk 2077

    Cyberpunk 2077

    75
    56 critic reviews·Dec 9, 2020·CD Projekt
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +2
    “Cyberpunk 2077 is a victim of bloat, but you can choose to ignore a lot of it and take in the sights.”
    — Destructoid · 75/100
  37. 37
    Eternal Threads

    Eternal Threads

    74
    18 critic reviews·May 18, 2022·Secret Mode
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Although Cosmonaut Studios' temporal narrative adventure doesn't capture the true gameplay potential of its trippy concept, the storytelling still makes it worth your time.Whether it's Life is Strange (Season One), The…”
    — VGChartz · 70/100
  38. 38
    The Wreck

    The Wreck

    72
    6 critic reviews·Mar 13, 2023·The Pixel Hunt
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “The Wreck is an ambitious game with a twisting web of narrative that, despite a few frustrating gameplay moments, admittedly brought me close to tears by the end.”
    — Jump Dash Roll · 70/100
  39. 39
    The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes

    The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes

    71
    26 critic reviews·Oct 21, 2021·Bandai Namco Entertainment
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes is the latest installment in the famous Dark Pictures Anthology, the game series that seeks to frighten its player”
    — Impulse Gamer · 70/100
  40. 40
    Vampyr

    Vampyr

    70
    50 critic reviews·Jun 4, 2018·Focus Entertainment
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Vampyr serves delicious ladles of angst and drama with a hearty slice of excellent, morally grey choice system that will genuinely surprise you, all wrapped up in a wonderfully gloomy London.”
    — Videogamer · 70/100
  41. 41
    High Times

    High Times

    70
    8 critic reviews·Jul 22, 2026·Yangyang Mobile
    PCSwitchPS5Xbox X|S
    “In its current state, I couldn’t recommend investing time into the Switch version of High Times. If work were put into shaping it into something more consumable, it would hold more appeal.”
    — RPGFan · 65/100
  42. 42
    Star Ocean: The Divine Force

    Star Ocean: The Divine Force

    70
    29 critic reviews·Oct 26, 2022·Square Enix
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “Star Ocean: The Divine Force is a throwback to the PS2-era, but that's part of what makes it fun.”
    — Game Skinny · 70/100
  43. 43
    Lost Records: Bloom & Rage

    Lost Records: Bloom & Rage

    70
    22 critic reviews·Feb 17, 2025·DON'T NOD
    PCXbox OnePS5Xbox X|S
    “Lost Records: Bloom and Rage is an engaging story-driven experience that has a couple of pitfalls stopping it from being amazing, and it is playable on the Steam Deck!”
    — Steam Deck HQ · 70/100
  44. 44
    The Casting of Frank Stone

    The Casting of Frank Stone

    69
    35 critic reviews·Sep 2, 2024·Behaviour Interactive
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “The Casting of Frank Stone takes Supermassive’s tried-and-true storytelling and mixes it with Dead by Daylight’s lore to tell a chilling, gruesome tale that’s highly replayable and accessible to non-DBD players.”
    — GameGrin · 70/100
  45. 45
    Lake

    Lake

    69
    17 critic reviews·Aug 31, 2021·Gamious
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Meredith has taken over her dad's mail route in picturesque Providence Oaks while he's on vacation so let's see if Lake delivers the goods.”
    — Video Chums · 70/100
  46. 46
    Dead Reset

    Dead Reset

    68
    10 critic reviews·Sep 10, 2025·Wales Interactive
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Dead Reset is a blood-soaked interactive horror, where each death brings you closer to the truth.”
    — Worth Playing · 70/100
  47. 47
    Biomutant

    Biomutant

    67
    58 critic reviews·May 24, 2021·THQ Nordic
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “As a $60 title, this one is a hard sell. There is enough content here, but I found it so repetitive that I wouldn’t imagine most would go through it.”
    — XboxEra · 68/100
  48. 48
    King's Bounty II

    King's Bounty II

    67
    19 critic reviews·Aug 22, 2021·1C Entertainment
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Good news—the prince has ordered your release from Crucis Prison. Bad news—you have to travel across a frozen land to go see him…immediately.”
    — Pure Nintendo · 65/100
  49. 49
    Alfred Hitchcock: Vertigo

    Alfred Hitchcock: Vertigo

    67
    7 critic reviews·Dec 15, 2021·Microids
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Watch a complex story unravel with many twists and turns in a modern nod to a classic film with Alfred Hitchcock: Vertigo.”
    — Video Chums · 75/100
  50. 50
    War Hospital

    War Hospital

    66
    11 critic reviews·Jan 10, 2024·Nacon
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “War Hospital is one of the better attempts at painting a gratifying picture of WW1 despite being held back by clunky UI and frequent bugs”
    — eXputer · 66/100
  51. 51
    Batora: Lost Haven

    Batora: Lost Haven

    65
    12 critic reviews·Oct 19, 2022·Team17
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Batora: Lost Haven is an isometric planet-hopping action RPG where you play as Avril, a teenager gifted with mysterious powers and tasked to save the Earth from catastrophe.”
    — Checkpoint Gaming · 60/100
  52. 52
    Fall of Porcupine

    Fall of Porcupine

    64
    9 critic reviews·Jun 14, 2023·Assemble Entertainment
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Whilst there are some interesting aspects, overall, Fall of Porcupine fell far below my expectations. I wouldn’t recommend getting this game unless you’re a fan of slow walking and reading.”
    — Screen Hype · 65/100
  53. 53
    Maid of Sker

    Maid of Sker

    62
    21 critic reviews·Jul 27, 2020·Perp Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “The designs of Elizabeth’s family aren’t so much foreshadowed as foreshouted, and the plot soon wavers off-key and winds up shipwrecked. But something about it hangs around, like the hum of an unsettling tune.”
    — Videogamer · 60/100
  54. 54
    Dollhouse: Behind the Broken Mirror

    Dollhouse: Behind the Broken Mirror

    37
    5 critic reviews·Feb 27, 2025·SOEDESCO Publishing
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
    “How ironic that Behind the Broken Mirror's most impressive accomplishment is shattering my subterranean expectations.If nothing else, SOEDESCO Publishing deserves credit for trying to reignite interest in what sounds…”
    — VGChartz · 25/100