
Best Choices Matter Games on PS4
The top 87 choices matter games on PS4 ranked by critic score · from 87 titles
CriticDB tracks 87 choices matter games on PS4 with critic scores. The highest-rated is Undertale (95), followed by Disco Elysium (92) and Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut (92). This top 87 draws on 1,537 critic reviews.
- 1

Undertale
9519 critic reviews·Sep 14, 2015·tobyfoxPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“Undertale, in its short lifespan, has already reached near legendary status. Unless you’ve been paying absolutely no attention to anything, you’ve heard a lot of people talk about the game, but if, like me, you’ve never…”
- 2

Disco Elysium
9229 critic reviews·Oct 14, 2019·ZA/UMPCPS4SwitchPS5“An intense role-playing odyssey, despite some overstuffed writing, Disco Elysium is an experience that has to be played to be believed.”
- 3

Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut
9210 critic reviews·Oct 23, 2024·Serenity ForgePCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Slay the Princess – The Pristine Cut is a fantastic visual novel with excellent production values and a lot of dialogue options.”
- 4

The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe
909 critic reviews·Apr 26, 2022·Crows Crows CrowsPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“The Stanley Parable is an extremely worthwhile video game and, I would argue, one of the finest examples of meta-humor (as well as humor in general) in the medium. Just don’t read too much before you play it.”
- 5

Deltarune
905 critic reviews·Jun 3, 2025·tobyfoxPCPS4SwitchPS5 +1“Even though the journey is only halfway to completion, Deltarune's incredible story is already bursting with hilarious charm, unforgettable characters, and an iconic soundtrack that make it worth investing your time in.”
- 6

Slay the Princess
9014 critic reviews·Oct 22, 2023·Black Tabby GamesPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut further polishes an already-splendid experience, adding more depth and replayability to one of 2023's best games.”
- 7

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
9013 critic reviews·Nov 9, 2011·Bethesda SoftworksPCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +4“Skyrim is easily one of the strongest and best examples of the Western RPG, and it further establishes Bethesda's reputation as one of the most talented and creative forces in the gaming industry.”
- 8

Disco Elysium: The Final Cut
8925 critic reviews·Mar 29, 2021·ZA/UMPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“The new content added to Disco Elysium: The Final Cut is exactly what is needed to turn a great game into an amazing one.”
- 9

Night in the Woods
8813 critic reviews·Feb 20, 2017·FinjiPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +1“Night in the Woods is basically everything I always hope games can be. Powerful and moving with gameplay that's clever, rewarding, and unique, all wrapped up in one of my favorite presentations. Don't pass this up.”
- 10

Zero Escape: Virtue's Last Reward
875 critic reviews·Feb 15, 2012·Rising Star GamesPCPS4Xbox One“This is what we need in our educational games. Scare the crap out of the kids and they'll definitely learn math.Well here we are again, a story focused game that I have to try and describe without screwing [...]”
- 11

Pyre
8725 critic reviews·Jul 24, 2017·Supergiant GamesPCPS4“Pyre is a party-based role-playing game in which you lead a band of exiles through an ancient competition spread across a vast, mystical purgatory.”
- 12

Steins;Gate 0
8612 critic reviews·Dec 9, 2015·Spike ChunsoftPCPS3PS4Xbox One +1“Although the darker themes may throw fans, Steins;Gate 0 tells a grand tale that fans of the series will still enjoy immensely due to how well the characters and story as a whole are written.”
- 13

Wayward Strand
8513 critic reviews·Sep 14, 2022·Ghost PatternPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Wayward Strand offers up a uniquely Australian take on the narrative adventure game with a gorgeous art direction and moving portrayal of hard-working people in a harsh system.”
- 14

Batman: The Enemy Within
846 critic reviews·Aug 7, 2017·Telltale GamesPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“I'll get the obvious out of the way now... it's episodic, it's frustrating to have to wait for the next part of the story (because it's so good) and I won't”
- 15

The Life and Suffering of Sir Brante
847 critic reviews·Mar 3, 2021·101XPPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“The Life And Suffering Of Sir Brante is a narrative-driven RPG that comes to life on the pages of the protagonist's journal.”
- 16

Citizen Sleeper
8418 critic reviews·May 4, 2022·Fellow TravellerPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +3“From its interesting design ideas to its rich world-building, Jump Over The Age's Citizen Sleeper is one of 2022's best surprises.”
- 17

Life is Strange: True Colors
8356 critic reviews·Sep 9, 2021·Square EnixPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“What True Colors lacks in the emotional gut-wrench that the previous games have, it makes it for with a refined format that presents a story that fits right into the series and tells it in the best way seen so far.”
- 18

Fortnite
837 critic reviews·Jun 28, 2020·Epic GamesPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +3“Nobody thought Fortnite would still be popular this late on, but it's continued to adapt and fight for its spot at the top of the battle royale ladder.”
- 19

Tactics Ogre: Reborn
8328 critic reviews·Nov 10, 2022·Square EnixPCPS4SwitchPS5“Tactics Ogre is a genre-defining SRPG that has certainly stood the test of time and it's now been Reborn for modern audiences.”
- 20

Far Cry 5
8343 critic reviews·Mar 25, 2018·Ubisoft EntertainmentPCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1“The Far Cry series takes its first trip to America with this explosive entry in Ubisoft's popular first-person shooter franchise.”
- 21

Far Cry 4
8325 critic reviews·Nov 17, 2014·Ubisoft EntertainmentPCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1“Graphics: 8.4 Gameplay: 8.0 Sound: 8.5 Control: 7.9 Replay Value: 8.3 Online Gameplay: 7.7 Overall Rating: 8.1 Publisher: Ubisoft Developer: Ubisoft Montrea ...”
- 22

Look Outside
837 critic reviews·Mar 20, 2025·Devolver DigitalPCPS4SwitchPS5 +1“One of the best survival horror games of the year and an impressively disturbing mix of EarthBound and The Thing, that also happens to be one of the best bargains of 2025.”
- 23

Oxenfree
8325 critic reviews·Jan 13, 2016·Night School StudioPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“Five teenagers unleash something unpleasant on a spooky island.”
- 24

Torment: Tides of Numenera
8228 critic reviews·Feb 26, 2017·TechlandPCPS4Xbox One“Torment: Tides of Numenera is a single-player role-playing game, set in the world of Monte Cook’s tabletop RPG game, that explores deep, personal themes.”
- 25

Paradise Killer
8222 critic reviews·Sep 3, 2020·Fellow TravellerPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“The first time I heard about Paradise Killer was in a random message on Discord from a friend of mine. The message simply said “You should play Paradise”
- 26

Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales
8126 critic reviews·Oct 22, 2018·CD Projekt REDPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales is a single-player, role-playing game set in the world of The Witcher that combines narrative-driven exploration with unique puzzles and card-battle mechanics.”
- 27

Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous
8119 critic reviews·Sep 1, 2021·Prime MatterPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Wrath of the Righteous is a deep, engaging, faithful recreation of the tabletop campaign with only minor flaws.”
- 28

Shadows Over Loathing
815 critic reviews·Nov 10, 2022·AsymmetricPCPS4SwitchPS5“Asymmetric Publications returns to the Loathing universe with Shadows Over Loathing.”
- 29

Black Book
8013 critic reviews·Aug 9, 2021·HypeTrain DigitalPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“There are plenty of periods in history that have long been neglected by the medium of games. 19th Century Russia is a good example of that. Fortunately, Russian”
- 30

Zero Escape: Zero Time Dilemma
809 critic reviews·Jun 27, 2016·Spike ChunsoftPCPS4Xbox One“Zero Time Dilemma is an immensely satisfying conclusion to what might be one of the best, best told stories in the history of the medium.”
- 31

Oxenfree II: Lost Signals
8029 critic reviews·Jul 11, 2023·NetflixPCPS4SwitchPS5“There are so many expectations to live up to after delivering the first Oxenfree, but Oxenfree II charts its own course, delivering something unlike Night School Studio's previous games.”
- 32

Sundered
8018 critic reviews·Jul 27, 2017·Thunder LotusPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +1“Sundered is an interesting take on the Metroidvania genre. Eshe's journey to collect the elder shards is adrenaline fueled and challenging.”
- 33

Baldur's Gate II: Enhanced Edition
808 critic reviews·Nov 14, 2013·BeamdogPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“It's hard, it's obtuse. It's big, it's beautiful. It's cruel, it's arbitrary. It's an adventure.”
- 34

Bramble: The Mountain King
7915 critic reviews·Apr 26, 2023·Dimfrost StudioPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Lillemore is one of the most rotten sisters in history. You’ll see why as we go along in Bramble: The Mountain King, Dimfrost Studios and Merge Games’ horror adventure that fully earns its M rating.Read More”
- 35

Heavy Rain
798 critic reviews·Feb 17, 2010·Sony Computer EntertainmentPCPS3PS4“In Heavy Rain, you don't watch the story – you play it. The dynamic narrative unfolds through the player's actions, not cut scenes, and every action has a consequence.”
- 36

Thirsty Suitors
7925 critic reviews·Nov 1, 2023·Annapurna InteractivePCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“In Thirsty Suitors, protagonist Jala has had a bad break-up and moved back to the hometown she left under the shadow of darkness, and back to the people she left high and dry.”
- 37

The Procession to Calvary
798 critic reviews·Apr 8, 2020·Digerati DistributionPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“Although sometimes frustrating and obtuse, The Procession to Calvary is a surreal and uniquely funny game well worth the pocket change you’ll spend on it.”
- 38

Goodbye Volcano High
7913 critic reviews·Aug 28, 2023·KO_OPPCPS4PS5“Goodbye Volcano High has definitely surprised me. Clearly KO_OP has a knack for this style of game, as this is one of the better narrative-heavy titles on the market.”
- 39

Life is Strange
7918 critic reviews·Jan 28, 2015·Feral InteractivePCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1“Life is Strange is a five-part episodic narrative driven adventure game that sets out to change story-based choice-and-consequence games by allowing the player to rewind time and affect the past, present and future.”
- 40

Ken Follett's The Pillars of the Earth
788 critic reviews·Aug 14, 2017·Daedalic EntertainmentPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“The Pillars of the Earth is a 2-D point-and-click adventure video game adaptation based on Ken Follett's best-selling novel.”
- 41

The Big Con
7811 critic reviews·Aug 30, 2021·Mighty YellPCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1“The Big Con is a blast from the past in its setting and story. While the tools to get you where you need to go need a bit of work, Ali is an exceptional main character, and playing through her story is a lot of fun.”
- 42

Dying Light 2: Stay Human
7735 critic reviews·Feb 2, 2022·Spike ChunsoftPCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1“Dying Light 2 is here after 6 years of development! You can tell care was put into this AAA title, but how is the overall gameplay, the co-op functionality, ...”
- 43

Far Cry 6
7747 critic reviews·Oct 6, 2021·Ubisoft EntertainmentPCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1“If Far Cry 3 was the last game you really got into, or the modern Far Cry formula is your meaty open-world experience of choice that somehow never loses its potency, you’ll find a lot of comfort in Far Cry 6.”
- 44

Endling: Extinction is Forever
7714 critic reviews·Jul 18, 2022·HandyGamesPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“I love animals. I love animals so much that in my excitement to review a game about cute foxes, I never saw the horrible truth of what this game really is... A”
- 45

Haven
7622 critic reviews·Dec 2, 2020·The Game BakersPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“When Furi first launched back in 2016 I was blown away by its high-octane, synthwave-infused, boss rush gameplay loop that was equal parts challenging as it was epic.”
- 46

Afterlove EP
7516 critic reviews·Feb 13, 2025·Fellow TravellerPCPS4SwitchPS5 +1“Afterlove EP pulls from a deep emotional well to weave threads of grief, love, hope, resentment, forgiveness, identity and more through a mostly-good mix of choice-driven visual novel and rhythm game.”
- 47

Persona 4: Dancing All Night
7520 critic reviews·Jun 24, 2015·NIS AmericaPS4“This fusion of visual novel of rhythm game isn’t exactly perfect, but speaking as someone who loves Persona (and Shoji Meguro’s work in particular), I really enjoyed my time with this one.”
- 48

Inkonbini
755 critic reviews·Apr 29, 2026·Beep JapanPCPS4SwitchPS5 +2“A warm, nostalgic story wrapped in the soothing rhythm of late-night convenience store life.”
- 49

Chaos;Child
7514 critic reviews·Dec 17, 2014·PQubePCPS3PS4Xbox One +1“Read our Chaos Child review to find out why the latest visual novel by 5pb is a shockingly violent visual novel that's a dark commentary on current society.”
- 50

Beyond: Two Souls
7519 critic reviews·Oct 7, 2013·Sony Computer EntertainmentPCPS3PS4“A deft remastering of what was arguably the PS3’s technical swansong, Beyond: Two Souls finds new life and an attractive home on PS4, with some extra features thrown in to sweeten the deal.”
- 51

Stray Gods: The Roleplaying Musical
7529 critic reviews·Aug 9, 2023·Humble GamesPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“After all, you’ll find some of the most engaging characters around since Gaider’s previous stint at BioWare, and a worthwhile story in this sleeper hit. I know I have my eyes on Summerfall Studios moving forward.”
- 52

Cyberpunk 2077
7556 critic reviews·Dec 9, 2020·CD ProjektPCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +2“Cyberpunk 2077 is a victim of bloat, but you can choose to ignore a lot of it and take in the sights.”
- 53

SaGa Frontier Remastered
7418 critic reviews·Apr 13, 2021·Square EnixPCPS4Switch“SaGa Frontier Remastered is a good slice of JRPG nostalgia that will please fans of the original classic.”
- 54

Dreamfall Chapters
7411 critic reviews·Oct 20, 2014·Red Thread GamesPCPS4Xbox One“The third entry in a Seventeen year old series, Dreamfall Chapters is an episodic title that, despite the solid mechanics and fairly engaging gameplay,”
- 55

Eternal Threads
7418 critic reviews·May 18, 2022·Secret ModePCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Although Cosmonaut Studios' temporal narrative adventure doesn't capture the true gameplay potential of its trippy concept, the storytelling still makes it worth your time.Whether it's Life is Strange (Season One), The…”
- 56

Dragon Quest
745 critic reviews·Feb 29, 2004·Square EnixPS4Switch“Dragon Quest, or Dragon Warrior as it was previously known in North America, is one of those NES games that was a standard of my childhood.”
- 57

Batman: The Telltale Series
7413 critic reviews·Aug 1, 2016·LCG EntertainmentPCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +2“We tell you, it’s a good game! It’s not average! It might have some problems here and there, but you have to admit it is a “Good” game.”
- 58

We Are OFK
7315 critic reviews·Aug 17, 2022·Team OFKPCPS4SwitchPS5“We Are OFK incorporates elements of a visual novel and a televised biopic to tell an emotionally rewarding story about a band coming together.”
- 59

The Council
737 critic reviews·Mar 12, 2018·Focus EntertainmentPCPS4Xbox One“A secretive Lord has invited influential world figures to a confidential meeting on a deserted island. For some reason, they all accept and arrive alone without any kind of protection.”
- 60

Stories: The Path of Destinies
7219 critic reviews·Apr 11, 2016·Spearhead GamesPCPS4Xbox One“Luckily, the joy of unfurling Stories’ myriad of tales makes up for its mechanical shortcomings.”
- 61

Afterparty
7227 critic reviews·Oct 28, 2019·Night School StudioPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“To summarise, Afterparty is a fun, bite-sized experience that lacks interactivity. The riddles are tremendously easy and the game almost plays itself.”
- 62

The Wreck
726 critic reviews·Mar 13, 2023·The Pixel HuntPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“The Wreck is an ambitious game with a twisting web of narrative that, despite a few frustrating gameplay moments, admittedly brought me close to tears by the end.”
- 63

The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes
7126 critic reviews·Oct 21, 2021·Bandai Namco EntertainmentPCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1“The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes is the latest installment in the famous Dark Pictures Anthology, the game series that seeks to frighten its player”
- 64

Where the Heart Leads
7116 critic reviews·Jul 12, 2021·Armature StudioPCPS4“Where The Heart Leads is a unique game that chronicles a family's entire life together, spanning generations and decades. It's ambitious, albeit flawed, but certainly interesting.”
- 65

Vampyr
7050 critic reviews·Jun 4, 2018·Focus EntertainmentPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Vampyr serves delicious ladles of angst and drama with a hearty slice of excellent, morally grey choice system that will genuinely surprise you, all wrapped up in a wonderfully gloomy London.”
- 66

Star Ocean: The Divine Force
7029 critic reviews·Oct 26, 2022·Square EnixPCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1“Star Ocean: The Divine Force is a throwback to the PS2-era, but that's part of what makes it fun.”
- 67

The Inpatient
6915 critic reviews·Jan 22, 2018·Sony Interactive EntertainmentPS4“By poking fun at slasher films and providing a captivating interactive horror experience, 2016’s Until Dawn was a pleasant surprise.”
- 68

The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing
6910 critic reviews·May 21, 2013·NeocoreGamesPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“The Incredible Adventures of Van Helsing is no second coming of Diablo II, but it's a fun, funny action-RPG with occasional glimmers of innovation.”
- 69

Undead Darlings: No Cure for Love
696 critic reviews·Sep 27, 2020·Sekai GamesPCPS4Switch“A fun dungeon romp with some fun characters that hold it all together. Average exploration and combat that doesn’t try anything unique but all in all a good time can be had here.”
- 70

Lake
6917 critic reviews·Aug 31, 2021·GamiousPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Meredith has taken over her dad's mail route in picturesque Providence Oaks while he's on vacation so let's see if Lake delivers the goods.”
- 71

Dead Reset
6810 critic reviews·Sep 10, 2025·Wales InteractivePCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Dead Reset is a blood-soaked interactive horror, where each death brings you closer to the truth.”
- 72

Shenmue III
6820 critic reviews·Nov 18, 2019·Shibuya ProductionsPCPS4“Shenmue III is an Unreal Engine 4-powered, open-world, action/RPG game that continues the legacy of the Shenmue franchise.”
- 73

Fallen Legion: Sins of an Empire
675 critic reviews·Jul 17, 2017·YummyYummyTummy Inc.PS4“Fallen Legion: Sins of an Empire shows more ambition than it probably had any financial right to show, and it pays off in some really surprising ways.”
- 74

Biomutant
6758 critic reviews·May 24, 2021·THQ NordicPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“As a $60 title, this one is a hard sell. There is enough content here, but I found it so repetitive that I wouldn’t imagine most would go through it.”
- 75

King's Bounty II
6719 critic reviews·Aug 22, 2021·1C EntertainmentPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Good news—the prince has ordered your release from Crucis Prison. Bad news—you have to travel across a frozen land to go see him…immediately.”
- 76

Alfred Hitchcock: Vertigo
677 critic reviews·Dec 15, 2021·MicroidsPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Watch a complex story unravel with many twists and turns in a modern nod to a classic film with Alfred Hitchcock: Vertigo.”
- 77

Hidden Agenda
668 critic reviews·Oct 23, 2017·Sony Interactive EntertainmentPS4“Behold, the choice-driven narrative serial killer crime drama party game genre is born.”
- 78

Princess Maker 2 Regeneration
668 critic reviews·Jul 10, 2024·Bliss BrainPCPS4SwitchPS5“Anyone in the gaming scene 30 years ago has probably heard about a simulation game that took the community by storm, Princess Maker 2. One of the biggest reasons dosboxes have existed is to play Princess Maker 2.”
- 79

Batora: Lost Haven
6512 critic reviews·Oct 19, 2022·Team17PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Batora: Lost Haven is an isometric planet-hopping action RPG where you play as Avril, a teenager gifted with mysterious powers and tasked to save the Earth from catastrophe.”
- 80

Skyhill
649 critic reviews·Oct 5, 2015·MandragoraPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“That said, when you get right down to the core of it, see how the elements work in your favour or conspire against you, Skyhill admirably creates this tense game of hubris and courage, one that never lets up until you…”
- 81

Fall of Porcupine
649 critic reviews·Jun 14, 2023·Assemble EntertainmentPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“Whilst there are some interesting aspects, overall, Fall of Porcupine fell far below my expectations. I wouldn’t recommend getting this game unless you’re a fan of slow walking and reading.”
- 82

This Is the Police
6417 critic reviews·Jul 26, 2016·THQ NordicPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“An intriguing concept hindered by too much going on. There are plenty of details throughout, but few received the attention they deserved.”
- 83

Maid of Sker
6221 critic reviews·Jul 27, 2020·Perp GamesPCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2“The designs of Elizabeth’s family aren’t so much foreshadowed as foreshouted, and the plot soon wavers off-key and winds up shipwrecked. But something about it hangs around, like the hum of an unsettling tune.”
- 84

Late Shift
629 critic reviews·Mar 8, 2016·Wales InteractivePCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +1“Late Shift is an FMV choose-your-own-adventure game where you find yourself wrapped-up in the middle of a heist and fumble into a crime-world conspiracy. It’”
- 85

Elex
5912 critic reviews·Oct 16, 2017·THQ NordicPCPS4Xbox One“Read PlayStation Lifestyle's ELEX PS4 review to find out if this RPG is worthy of its inspirations. Enter the world of Edan!”
- 86

Fade to Silence
5915 critic reviews·Apr 29, 2018·THQ NordicPCPS4Xbox One“Many considered the survival genre to be overcrowded, with numerous titles in the genre being released every year.”
- 87

Those Who Remain
5816 critic reviews·May 27, 2020·Camel 101PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch“Those Who Remain features an eerie atmosphere, inventive puzzles, and some moments of genuine tension via its shape-shifting world, but fussy controls, one-dimensional stealth, and a narrative that lacks cohesion…”