Undertale artwork

Best Psychological Horror Games on Xbox One

The top 44 psychological horror games on Xbox One ranked by critic score · from 44 titles

CriticDB tracks 44 psychological horror games on Xbox One with critic scores. The highest-rated is Undertale (95), followed by Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut (92) and Mouthwashing (90). This top 44 draws on 817 critic reviews.

  1. 1
    Undertale

    Undertale

    95
    19 critic reviews·Sep 14, 2015·tobyfox
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “Undertale, in its short lifespan, has already reached near legendary status. Unless you’ve been paying absolutely no attention to anything, you’ve heard a lot of people talk about the game, but if, like me, you’ve never…”
    — WCCFtech · 95/100
  2. 2
    Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut

    Slay the Princess: The Pristine Cut

    92
    10 critic reviews·Oct 23, 2024·Serenity Forge
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Slay the Princess – The Pristine Cut is a fantastic visual novel with excellent production values and a lot of dialogue options.”
    — XboxEra · 92/100
  3. 3
    Mouthwashing

    Mouthwashing

    90
    20 critic reviews·Sep 25, 2024·Critical Reflex
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Review: First-person horror Mouthwashing will keep you on the edge of your seat as you unravel its dark and gripping story.”
    — GameSpew · 90/100
  4. 4
    Resident Evil 7: Biohazard

    Resident Evil 7: Biohazard

    87
    33 critic reviews·Jan 23, 2017·Capcom
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +2
    “The Resident Evil series has had a profound effect on me as a gamer – The original game was the first title I played on the PlayStation and I remember 13 year”
    — Impulse Gamer · 88/100
  5. 5
    Zero Escape: Virtue's Last Reward

    Zero Escape: Virtue's Last Reward

    87
    5 critic reviews·Feb 15, 2012·Rising Star Games
    PCPS4Xbox One
    “This is what we need in our educational games. Scare the crap out of the kids and they'll definitely learn math.Well here we are again, a story focused game that I have to try and describe without screwing [...]”
    — VGChartz · 90/100
  6. 6
    Dredge

    Dredge

    85
    32 critic reviews·Mar 29, 2023·Team17
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Prepare for a fishing trip filled with hapless inhabitants, mysterious far-flung islands, and seas that are brimming with deep, dark secrets.”
    — Worth Playing · 85/100
  7. 7
    Signalis

    Signalis

    85
    24 critic reviews·Oct 26, 2022·Humble Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +1
    “Signalis is a classic survival-horror experience with a unique aesthetic, full of melancholic mystery.”
    — Worth Playing · 85/100
  8. 8
    Control

    Control

    84
    48 critic reviews·Aug 26, 2019·505 Games
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “When the issues of a game are rolled and stomped by its greatness, then it’s something to invest on if you have some spare.”
    — Sirus Gaming · 83/100
  9. 9
    Doki Doki Literature Club Plus!

    Doki Doki Literature Club Plus!

    82
    14 critic reviews·Jun 29, 2021·Serenity Forge
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +1
    “Doki Doki Literature Club doesn’t disappoint as an off-kilter visual novel. If you, like me, tend to avoid this genre, you might consider DDLC as an exception to the rule if you can handle some disturbing content.”
    — Nintendo World Report · 80/100
  10. 10
    Routine

    Routine

    81
    21 critic reviews·Dec 3, 2025·Raw Fury
    PCXbox OneXbox X|S
    “ROUTINE may have been a long time coming, but it’s definitely well worth the experience now that it’s finally here, especially for fans of the horror genre.”
    — GamingBolt · 80/100
  11. 11
    Observer: System Redux

    Observer: System Redux

    81
    19 critic reviews·Nov 9, 2020·Bloober Team
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +2
    “A graphical feast that seamlessly blends a multilayered, psychological horror narrative with heart-poundingly and intimate gameplay, Observer: System Redux is an exquisite piece of cyberpunk fiction.”
    — NoobFeed · 90/100
  12. 12
    Raging Loop

    Raging Loop

    81
    5 critic reviews·Dec 2, 2015·PQube
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “While it takes a while to establish the plot, Raging Loop is a visual novel that’s grisly and heartfelt.”
    — GamingTrend · 80/100
  13. 13
    Darkest Dungeon II

    Darkest Dungeon II

    80
    26 critic reviews·May 7, 2023·Red Hook Studios
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +3
    “Darkest Dungeon II is a challenging gothic roguelike RPG that will test your mettle and drive you to the brink of madness.”
    — Worth Playing · 80/100
  14. 14
    Zero Escape: Zero Time Dilemma

    Zero Escape: Zero Time Dilemma

    80
    9 critic reviews·Jun 27, 2016·Spike Chunsoft
    PCPS4Xbox One
    “Zero Time Dilemma is an immensely satisfying conclusion to what might be one of the best, best told stories in the history of the medium.”
    — GamingBolt · 80/100
  15. 15
    Alien: Isolation

    Alien: Isolation

    80
    30 critic reviews·Oct 5, 2014·Sega
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +2
    “Alien Isolation is the game fans have waited decades for; a tense, unforgiving survival horror that finally does the franchise justice.”
    — The OuterHaven · 80/100
  16. 16
    Amnesia: Rebirth

    Amnesia: Rebirth

    80
    35 critic reviews·Oct 19, 2020·Frictional Games
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +2
    “The follow-up to Frictional Games' seminal 2010 horror game tightly hones the developer's approach to story, frights, and frustration.”
    — GameSpot · 80/100
  17. 17
    Amnesia: The Bunker

    Amnesia: The Bunker

    79
    41 critic reviews·Jun 5, 2023·Frictional Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneXbox X|S
    “The year is 1916. You are Henri Clement, a French soldier fighting in World War I. You went searching for your friend on the battlefield, and, after getting”
    — Impulse Gamer · 80/100
  18. 18
    Outlast

    Outlast

    78
    9 critic reviews·Sep 3, 2013·Red Barrels
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “Outlast is one of, if not the scariest game I’ve played. It’s creepy, suspenseful and terrifying at times.”
    — TheSixthAxis · 80/100
  19. 19
    The Outlast Trials

    The Outlast Trials

    78
    28 critic reviews·Mar 4, 2024·Red Barrels
    PCPlayStationXboxPS4 +4
    “Red Barrels' third Outlast game is a departure in many ways, but remains memorable for its twisted villains and the grotesque world they inhabit.”
    — GameSpot · 80/100
  20. 20
    Clem

    Clem

    77
    7 critic reviews·Feb 5, 2024·Iceberg Interactive
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Despite the occasional patience-testing puzzle, CLeM’s inventive gameplay and exploratory style make this quirky hand-drawn “Psychotic Adventure” worth a peek.”
    — Adventure Game Hotspot · 78/100
  21. 21
    Song of Horror

    Song of Horror

    77
    9 critic reviews·Oct 30, 2019·Raiser Games
    PCPS4Xbox One
    “We tell you, it’s a good game! It’s not average! It might have some problems here and there, but you have to admit it is a “Good” game.”
    — Sirus Gaming · 75/100
  22. 22
    Little Nightmares

    Little Nightmares

    77
    36 critic reviews·Apr 27, 2017·Bandai Namco Entertainment
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “Little Nightmares is a game that often makes you feel helpless. You play a child in a place she doesn’t belong and everything wants to either kill you or eat you.”
    — WCCFtech · 78/100
  23. 23
    Visage

    Visage

    75
    8 critic reviews·Oct 28, 2020·SadSquare Studio
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5
    “Still, with these minor annoyances aside, Visage goes far beyond cheap jump scares and will chill you to the bone if you give it half a chance.”
    — GameSpew · 70/100
  24. 24
    The Infectious Madness of Doctor Dekker

    The Infectious Madness of Doctor Dekker

    74
    10 critic reviews·May 18, 2017·Wales Interactive
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “The Infectious Madness of Doctor Dekker landed on PC in May of last year, where it received highly [...]”
    — VGChartz · 70/100
  25. 25
    Observation

    Observation

    74
    33 critic reviews·May 20, 2019·Devolver Digital
    PCPS4Xbox One
    “A thrilling experience in outer space.Ever since the first scientific discoveries, and doubly so with the growth of the science-fiction genre, space and the [...]”
    — VGChartz · 70/100
  26. 26
    No One Lives Under the Lighthouse

    No One Lives Under the Lighthouse

    73
    5 critic reviews·Apr 20, 2020·Puppet Combo
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “No One Lives Under the Lighthouse is a game that horror fans should definitely check out, especially if the retro aesthetic appeals to them.”
    — GameSpew · 70/100
  27. 27
    The Park

    The Park

    72
    13 critic reviews·Oct 26, 2015·Funcom
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “A chilling story about simple horrors, strong art design, and voice acting help tie together this horror short into a package worth checking out for horror fans.”
    — TechRaptor · 75/100
  28. 28
    Layers of Fear 2

    Layers of Fear 2

    71
    35 critic reviews·May 27, 2019·Gun Interactive
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “Layers of Fear 2 ups the ante from the original game's haunted house simulator style of horror, but that still leaves it all feeling too scripted to instill any real sense of dread.”
    — Game Skinny · 70/100
  29. 29
    Remothered: Tormented Fathers

    Remothered: Tormented Fathers

    70
    10 critic reviews·Jan 29, 2018·Darril Arts
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “An effective homage to Clock Tower that manages to create a similar sense of helplessness even if it doesn’t improve on the formula in any notable way.”
    — Metro GameCentral · 70/100
  30. 30
    Transference

    Transference

    70
    19 critic reviews·Sep 17, 2018·Ubisoft Entertainment
    PCPS4Xbox One
    “A short, but intense horror adventure experience in VR.Virtual reality made quite an impression in its early days, but since then, and despite regular releases, it [...]”
    — VGChartz · 70/100
  31. 31
    The Cabin Factory

    The Cabin Factory

    70
    5 critic reviews·Dec 12, 2024·Future Friends Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Your job at the Cabin Factory is simple: inspect the cabins and decide on whether they’re haunted or not. If you do find any anomalies, get out…immediately. PC version reviewed.”
    — Siliconera · 70/100
  32. 32
    Get Even

    Get Even

    70
    17 critic reviews·Jun 22, 2017·Bandai Namco Entertainment
    PCPS4Xbox One
    “Get Even's use of layered sound and even more layered story is unsettling and great, but other awkward mechanics make this psychological thriller a bit less than the sum of some very fine parts.”
    — Videogamer · 70/100
  33. 33
    Conarium

    Conarium

    70
    14 critic reviews·Jun 5, 2017·Iceberg Interactive
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “Conarium is hauntingly beautiful and competent as an adventure-puzzle game with some light horror elements, but as a true H.P. Lovecraft survival horror game it isn't long or scary enough.”
    — Gaming Nexus · 74/100
  34. 34
    Fobia: St. Dinfna Hotel

    Fobia: St. Dinfna Hotel

    68
    17 critic reviews·Jun 27, 2022·Maximum Games
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “Fobia – St. Dinfna Hotel is worth playing for patient survival horror fans who want something lighter on combat, and can handle budget-constrained rough edges.”
    — Destructoid · 65/100
  35. 35
    The Bunker

    The Bunker

    67
    11 critic reviews·Sep 19, 2016·Wales Interactive
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +1
    “As a game, it might bring all this goodwill down a peg, but it never once feels like you’ve wasted your time. At worst, it’s like you’ve watched a great horror/thriller with a faulty remote by your side.”
    — Destructoid · 70/100
  36. 36
    The Inner Friend

    The Inner Friend

    67
    7 critic reviews·Sep 5, 2018·PLAYMIND
    PCPS4Xbox One
    “Horror games aren’t always just about jump scares and gore. They can have deep, underlying messages about our darkest fears and deepest traumas.”
    — Playstation Lifestyle · 70/100
  37. 37
    Kholat

    Kholat

    66
    11 critic reviews·Jun 8, 2015·IMGN.PRO
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “Kholat is a welcome challenging and atmospheric take on the horror genre”
    — TechRaptor · 70/100
  38. 38
    Blair Witch

    Blair Witch

    64
    38 critic reviews·Aug 29, 2019·Bloober Team
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “Technical troubles and predictability hurt what is otherwise a heart-pumping horror with a story worth uncovering.”
    — WellPlayed · 60/100
  39. 39
    Bad Cheese

    Bad Cheese

    63
    8 critic reviews·Aug 31, 2025·Feardemic
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “I thoroughly enjoyed my time with Bad Cheese and would recommend it to anyone who likes things on the weirder side of life.”
    — Gamer Social Club · 65/100
  40. 40
    Black Mirror

    Black Mirror

    60
    19 critic reviews·Nov 27, 2017·THQ Nordic
    PCPS4Xbox One
    “Black Mirror, a revival of the 2003 adventure game The Black Mirror, tells an all-new tale of murder, deceit, and powerful magic surrounding the Gordon family.”
    — Game Informer · 60/100
  41. 41
    We Happy Few

    We Happy Few

    59
    33 critic reviews·Aug 9, 2018·Gearbox Publishing
    PCPS4Xbox One
    “After a long and turbulent development period and an early access release, We Happy Few is finally available in its (mostly) finished form. However, does it have what it takes to make this reviewer happy?”
    — Video Chums · 58/100
  42. 42
    Chasing Static

    Chasing Static

    58
    8 critic reviews·Oct 13, 2021·Ratalaika Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
    “Spotty connection of certain design & narrative choices aside, Headware Games' retro-horror title will do just enough to keep fans from changing the channel.One of the industry’s most intriguing resurgences is the…”
    — VGChartz · 60/100
  43. 43
    Pneumata

    Pneumata

    48
    7 critic reviews·Sep 19, 2024·Deadbolt Interactive
    PCPS4Xbox OnePS5 +1
    “What’s the biggest advantage of being a solo developer? You work on your own. And the biggest disadvantage? Also: you work on your own. As a result, an”
    — Impulse Gamer · 56/100
  44. 44
    Agony

    Agony

    40
    9 critic reviews·May 28, 2018·Forever Entertainment S.A.
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
    “Agony is, true to its name and intentions, a hellish experience. My excitement for the game was quickly quashed behind bugs, crashes and unbalanced gameplay, failing to live up to the potential of the game’s core ideas…”
    — TheSixthAxis · 40/100