Stardew Valley artwork

Best Crafting Games of All Time

The top 16 crafting games ranked by critic score · from 16 titles

The highest-rated crafting game is Stardew Valley with a critic score of 91 from 25 reviews, followed by Animal Crossing: New Horizons (89) and Valheim (89). Scores are aggregated from leading gaming publications worldwide.

Updated November 2026

  1. 1
    Stardew Valley

    Stardew Valley

    91
    25 critic reviews·Feb 25, 2016·Chucklefish Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +1
  2. 2
    Animal Crossing: New Horizons

    Animal Crossing: New Horizons

    89
    49 critic reviews·Mar 19, 2020·Nintendo
    Switch
  3. 3
    Valheim

    Valheim

    89
    17 critic reviews·Sep 8, 2026·Coffee Stain Publishing
    PCXbox OnePS5Xbox X|S +1
  4. 4
    Core Keeper

    Core Keeper

    83
    11 critic reviews·Aug 26, 2024·Fireshine Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +3
  5. 5
    Sons of the Forest

    Sons of the Forest

    82
    6 critic reviews·Feb 21, 2024·Newnight
    PC
  6. 6
    Story of Seasons: Grand Bazaar

    Story of Seasons: Grand Bazaar

    81
    37 critic reviews·Aug 26, 2025·XSEED Games
    PCSwitchPS5Xbox X|S +1
  7. 7
    Subnautica

    Subnautica

    81
    20 critic reviews·Jan 22, 2018·Unknown Worlds Entertainment
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +3
  8. 8
    Pacific Drive

    Pacific Drive

    80
    30 critic reviews·Feb 21, 2024·Kepler Interactive
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
  9. 9
    Wild Hearts

    Wild Hearts

    78
    51 critic reviews·Feb 15, 2023·Electronic Arts
    PCPS5Xbox X|S
  10. 10
    RuneScape: Dragonwilds

    RuneScape: Dragonwilds

    77
    17 critic reviews·Sep 14, 2026·Jagex
    PCPS5Xbox X|SSwitch 2
  11. 11
    My Time at Sandrock

    My Time at Sandrock

    77
    27 critic reviews·Nov 1, 2023·Pathea Games
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
  12. 12
    Fae Farm

    Fae Farm

    75
    32 critic reviews·Sep 7, 2023·Phoenix Labs
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
  13. 13
    Wild Hearts S

    Wild Hearts S

    75
    15 critic reviews·Jul 24, 2025·Koei Tecmo Games
    Switch 2
  14. 14
    My Time at Portia

    My Time at Portia

    72
    29 critic reviews·Jan 14, 2019·Team17
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch
  15. 15
    Potion Permit

    Potion Permit

    71
    22 critic reviews·Sep 21, 2022·Playdigious
    PCPS4Xbox OneSwitch +2
  16. 16
    Tamagotchi Plaza

    Tamagotchi Plaza

    49
    16 critic reviews·Jun 26, 2025·Bandai Namco Entertainment
    Switch