Batman: Arkham Asylum artwork
← All Xbox 360 Games

Best Xbox 360 Games of 2009

28 Xbox 360 games from 2009 ranked by critic score

The highest-rated Xbox 360 games released in 2009, ranked by critics on CriticDB. Scores are aggregated from leading gaming publications worldwide.

  1. 1
    Batman: Arkham Asylum

    Batman: Arkham Asylum

    94
    9 critic reviews·Aug 24, 2009·Playcast-media
    PCPS3Xbox 360Switch
  2. 2
    Left 4 Dead 2

    Left 4 Dead 2

    92
    6 critic reviews·Nov 16, 2009·Valve
    PCXbox 360
  3. 3
    Bayonetta

    Bayonetta

    89
    6 critic reviews·Oct 28, 2009·Sega
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  4. 4
    Brütal Legend

    Brütal Legend

    88
    8 critic reviews·Oct 12, 2009·Electronic Arts
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  5. 5
    Plants vs. Zombies

    Plants vs. Zombies

    88
    11 critic reviews·May 4, 2009·PopCap Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  6. 6
    Trials HD

    Trials HD

    86
    5 critic reviews·Aug 11, 2009·Microsoft Game Studios
    PCXbox 360Xbox One
  7. 7
    Halo 3: ODST

    Halo 3: ODST

    86
    6 critic reviews·Sep 21, 2009·Microsoft Game Studios
    PCXbox 360Xbox One
  8. 8
    Dragon Age: Origins

    Dragon Age: Origins

    84
    8 critic reviews·Nov 2, 2009·Electronic Arts
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  9. 9
    Final Fantasy XIII

    Final Fantasy XIII

    83
    6 critic reviews·Dec 16, 2009·Square Enix
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  10. 10
    Assassin's Creed II

    Assassin's Creed II

    83
    12 critic reviews·Nov 16, 2009·Ubisoft Entertainment
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  11. 11
    Need for Speed: Shift

    Need for Speed: Shift

    83
    9 critic reviews·Sep 14, 2009·Electronic Arts
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  12. 12
    Battlefield 1943

    Battlefield 1943

    81
    5 critic reviews·Jul 7, 2009·Electronic Arts
    PS3Xbox 360
  13. 13
    Might & Magic: Clash of Heroes

    Might & Magic: Clash of Heroes

    80
    5 critic reviews·Nov 30, 2009·Capybara Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  14. 14
    Mini Ninjas

    Mini Ninjas

    78
    7 critic reviews·Sep 7, 2009·Eidos Interactive
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  15. 15
    Resident Evil 5

    Resident Evil 5

    77
    10 critic reviews·Mar 4, 2009·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  16. 16
    Rocket Riot

    Rocket Riot

    77
    5 critic reviews·Jun 16, 2009·Codeglue
    PCXbox 360
  17. 17
    R-Type Dimensions

    R-Type Dimensions

    77
    6 critic reviews·Feb 3, 2009·Tozai Games, Inc.
    PS3Xbox 360
  18. 18
    Torchlight

    Torchlight

    76
    6 critic reviews·Oct 26, 2009·Encore
    PCXbox 360
  19. 19
    Zuma's Revenge!

    Zuma's Revenge!

    76
    5 critic reviews·Sep 14, 2009·Electronic Arts
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  20. 20
    Star Ocean: The Last Hope

    Star Ocean: The Last Hope

    74
    8 critic reviews·Feb 18, 2009·Square Enix
    PS3Xbox 360
  21. 21
    Borderlands

    Borderlands

    72
    14 critic reviews·Oct 19, 2009·Feral Interactive
    PCPS3Xbox 360Xbox One +1
  22. 22
    Call of Juarez: Bound In Blood

    Call of Juarez: Bound In Blood

    72
    7 critic reviews·Jun 29, 2009·Techland
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  23. 23
    Overlord II

    Overlord II

    68
    6 critic reviews·Jun 22, 2009·Codemasters
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  24. 24
    Marvel: Ultimate Alliance 2

    Marvel: Ultimate Alliance 2

    68
    11 critic reviews·Sep 14, 2009·Activision
    PCPS2PS3Xbox 360 +2
  25. 25
    Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince

    Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince

    66
    6 critic reviews·Jun 29, 2009·Electronic Arts
    PCPS2PS3Xbox 360
  26. 26
    The Saboteur

    The Saboteur

    65
    6 critic reviews·Dec 3, 2009·Electronic Arts
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  27. 27
    Jet Car Stunts

    Jet Car Stunts

    64
    5 critic reviews·Nov 12, 2009·True Axis Pty. Ltd.
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  28. 28
    Wanted: Weapons of Fate

    Wanted: Weapons of Fate

    58
    7 critic reviews·Mar 16, 2009·WB Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360