Batman: Arkham Asylum artwork

Best Xbox 360 Horror Games

67 highest-rated Xbox 360 horror games ranked by critic score · 67 scored in total

The highest-rated Xbox 360 horror game is Batman: Arkham Asylum with a critic score of 94 from 9 reviews, followed by Left 4 Dead 2 (92) and Diablo III (90). Scores are aggregated from leading gaming publications worldwide.

Updated November 2026

Best Horror Games on every platform · Best Xbox 360 games of all time

  1. 1
    Batman: Arkham Asylum

    Batman: Arkham Asylum

    94
    9 critic reviews·Aug 24, 2009·Playcast-media
    PCPS3Xbox 360Switch
  2. 2
    Left 4 Dead 2

    Left 4 Dead 2

    92
    6 critic reviews·Nov 16, 2009·Valve
    PCXbox 360
  3. 3
    Diablo III

    Diablo III

    90
    11 critic reviews·May 14, 2012·Square Enix
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  4. 4
    The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode 2: A House Divided

    The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode 2: A House Divided

    90
    11 critic reviews·Mar 3, 2014·Telltale Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  5. 5
    Left 4 Dead

    Left 4 Dead

    90
    6 critic reviews·Nov 16, 2008·Electronic Arts
    PCXbox 360
  6. 6
    Gears of War 3

    Gears of War 3

    90
    9 critic reviews·Sep 19, 2011·Microsoft Studios
    Xbox 360Xbox One
  7. 7
    Diablo III: Reaper of Souls

    Diablo III: Reaper of Souls

    88
    14 critic reviews·Mar 24, 2014·Square Enix
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  8. 8
    Alan Wake

    Alan Wake

    88
    7 critic reviews·May 13, 2010·Nordic Games Publishing
    PCXbox 360
  9. 9
    BioShock Infinite

    BioShock Infinite

    86
    16 critic reviews·Feb 25, 2013·2K Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  10. 10
    The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode 5: No Going Back

    The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode 5: No Going Back

    86
    7 critic reviews·Aug 26, 2014·Telltale Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  11. 11
    Dead Space 2

    Dead Space 2

    86
    11 critic reviews·Jan 24, 2011·Electronic Arts
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  12. 12
    Limbo

    Limbo

    85
    10 critic reviews·Jul 20, 2010·Microsoft Game Studios
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +2
  13. 13
    Call of Duty: World at War

    Call of Duty: World at War

    85
    7 critic reviews·Nov 10, 2008·Activision
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  14. 14
    State of Decay

    State of Decay

    83
    9 critic reviews·Jun 4, 2013·Microsoft Studios
    PCXbox 360
  15. 15
    BloodRayne: Betrayal

    BloodRayne: Betrayal

    82
    5 critic reviews·Sep 5, 2011·Majesco Entertainment
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  16. 16
    Resident Evil

    Resident Evil

    81
    9 critic reviews·Nov 26, 2014·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +2
  17. 17
    The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode 1: All That Remains

    The Walking Dead: Season Two - Episode 1: All That Remains

    81
    6 critic reviews·Dec 16, 2013·Telltale Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  18. 18
    Alien: Isolation

    Alien: Isolation

    80
    30 critic reviews·Oct 5, 2014·Sega
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +2
  19. 19
    The Evil Within: The Assignment

    The Evil Within: The Assignment

    80
    5 critic reviews·Mar 8, 2015·Bethesda Softworks
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  20. 20
    Resident Evil 5

    Resident Evil 5

    80
    9 critic reviews·Mar 4, 2009·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  21. 21
    Metro: Last Light

    Metro: Last Light

    79
    13 critic reviews·May 13, 2013·Deep Silver
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  22. 22
    Shadows of the Damned

    Shadows of the Damned

    79
    7 critic reviews·Jun 20, 2011·Electronic Arts
    PS3Xbox 360
  23. 23
    Call of Duty: Black Ops

    Call of Duty: Black Ops

    79
    12 critic reviews·Nov 8, 2010·Square Enix
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  24. 24
    Terraria

    Terraria

    79
    12 critic reviews·May 15, 2011·505 Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +2
  25. 25
    Castlevania: Lords of Shadow

    Castlevania: Lords of Shadow

    79
    9 critic reviews·Oct 4, 2010·Konami
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  26. 26
    The Walking Dead: 400 Days

    The Walking Dead: 400 Days

    78
    12 critic reviews·Jul 1, 2013·Telltale Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  27. 27
    Dying Light

    Dying Light

    77
    32 critic reviews·Jan 25, 2015·WB Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +3
  28. 28
    Alan Wake's American Nightmare

    Alan Wake's American Nightmare

    77
    7 critic reviews·Feb 21, 2012·Nordic Games Publishing
    PCXbox 360
  29. 29
    Metro 2033

    Metro 2033

    76
    7 critic reviews·Mar 15, 2010·THQ
    PCXbox 360
  30. 30
    Catherine

    Catherine

    75
    6 critic reviews·Feb 16, 2011·Deep Silver
    PS3Xbox 360
  31. 31
    The Darkness II

    The Darkness II

    75
    5 critic reviews·Feb 6, 2012·2K Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  32. 32
    Resident Evil: Revelations

    Resident Evil: Revelations

    75
    17 critic reviews·May 19, 2013·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +2
  33. 33
    Resident Evil: Revelations 2

    Resident Evil: Revelations 2

    74
    26 critic reviews·Feb 23, 2015·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +2
  34. 34
    Skullgirls

    Skullgirls

    74
    9 critic reviews·Apr 9, 2012·CyberFront
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  35. 35
    Dark Sector

    Dark Sector

    74
    7 critic reviews·Mar 24, 2008·D3 Publisher
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  36. 36
    Dead Rising 2

    Dead Rising 2

    73
    9 critic reviews·Sep 23, 2010·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  37. 37
    The Evil Within

    The Evil Within

    72
    24 critic reviews·Oct 13, 2014·Bethesda Softworks
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  38. 38
    F.E.A.R. 3

    F.E.A.R. 3

    72
    5 critic reviews·Jun 20, 2011·WB Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  39. 39
    Prototype 2

    Prototype 2

    71
    7 critic reviews·Apr 23, 2012·Activision
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  40. 40
    Red Faction: Armageddon

    Red Faction: Armageddon

    71
    8 critic reviews·Jun 5, 2011·Syfy Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  41. 41
    Devil May Cry HD Collection

    Devil May Cry HD Collection

    71
    14 critic reviews·Mar 21, 2012·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  42. 42
    Aliens vs. Predator

    Aliens vs. Predator

    71
    6 critic reviews·Feb 15, 2010·Sega
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  43. 43
    Dead Space 3

    Dead Space 3

    70
    17 critic reviews·Feb 4, 2013·Electronic Arts
    PCPS3Xbox 360Xbox One
  44. 44
    Alice: Madness Returns

    Alice: Madness Returns

    70
    7 critic reviews·Jun 13, 2011·Electronic Arts
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  45. 45
    Resident Evil 0

    Resident Evil 0

    69
    7 critic reviews·Jan 18, 2016·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +2
  46. 46
    I Am Alive

    I Am Alive

    69
    8 critic reviews·Mar 6, 2012·Ubisoft Entertainment
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  47. 47
    Dead Rising 2: Off the Record

    Dead Rising 2: Off the Record

    69
    8 critic reviews·Oct 10, 2011·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  48. 48
    The Walking Dead: Michonne

    The Walking Dead: Michonne

    69
    6 critic reviews·Feb 2, 2016·Telltale Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  49. 49
    Dante's Inferno

    Dante's Inferno

    69
    6 critic reviews·Feb 3, 2010·Electronic Arts
    PS3Xbox 360
  50. 50
    Deadlight

    Deadlight

    69
    8 critic reviews·Jul 31, 2012·Microsoft Studios
    PCXbox 360
  51. 51
    Dead Island

    Dead Island

    67
    9 critic reviews·Sep 5, 2011·Deep Silver
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  52. 52
    Resident Evil 6

    Resident Evil 6

    66
    17 critic reviews·Oct 1, 2012·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  53. 53
    Saints Row: Gat Out of Hell

    Saints Row: Gat Out of Hell

    66
    14 critic reviews·Jan 19, 2015·Deep Silver
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  54. 54
    How to Survive

    How to Survive

    63
    7 critic reviews·Oct 22, 2013·505 Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  55. 55
    Dead Island: Riptide

    Dead Island: Riptide

    61
    13 critic reviews·Apr 22, 2013·Deep Silver
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  56. 56
    Slender: The Arrival

    Slender: The Arrival

    61
    15 critic reviews·Mar 25, 2013·Blue Isle Studios
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +2
  57. 57
    Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 2

    Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 2

    60
    15 critic reviews·Feb 24, 2014·Konami
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  58. 58
    Murdered: Soul Suspect

    Murdered: Soul Suspect

    58
    21 critic reviews·Jun 2, 2014·Square Enix
    PCPS3Xbox 360PS4 +1
  59. 59
    Yaiba: Ninja Gaiden Z

    Yaiba: Ninja Gaiden Z

    51
    16 critic reviews·Mar 17, 2014·Koei Tecmo Games
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  60. 60
    Rise of Nightmares

    Rise of Nightmares

    50
    5 critic reviews·Sep 5, 2011
    Xbox 360
  61. 61
    Escape Dead Island

    Escape Dead Island

    48
    10 critic reviews·Nov 17, 2014·Deep Silver
    PCPS3Xbox 360Xbox One
  62. 62
    Resident Evil: Operation Raccoon City

    Resident Evil: Operation Raccoon City

    44
    8 critic reviews·Mar 19, 2012·Capcom
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  63. 63
    NeverDead

    NeverDead

    42
    7 critic reviews·Jan 30, 2012·Konami
    PS3Xbox 360
  64. 64
    Bullet Witch

    Bullet Witch

    39
    6 critic reviews·Jul 26, 2006·AQ Interactive
    PCXbox 360
  65. 65
    Aliens: Colonial Marines

    Aliens: Colonial Marines

    37
    11 critic reviews·Feb 11, 2013·Sega
    PCPS3Xbox 360
  66. 66
    Naughty Bear

    Naughty Bear

    36
    7 critic reviews·Jun 24, 2010·505 Games
    PS3Xbox 360
  67. 67
    Amy

    Amy

    31
    5 critic reviews·Jan 10, 2012·Microids
    PS3Xbox 360